The Efficiency of the Shield Punt Scheme

Jan 23, 2012 | Special Teams, Punt

By Mike Kuchar

Research Manager

X&O Labs

Researchers' Note: You can access the raw data - in the form of graphs - from our research on the shield punt: Click here to read the Statistical Analysis Report.

If you watched all thirty some odd bowl games season, we’d wager that a game didn’t go by were at least one team didn’t use the shield punt formation (Diagram 1).  The fact is it’s all over the college landscape.  While we couldn’t trace its roots or origins (although we do have Bill Stewart from West Virginia reflecting on it below) it spread quickly, at least in the college ranks.  As a high school defensive coordinator in central New Jersey, I have yet to face it in the last eight years - and as X&O Labs started to conduct its research on the topic, I’m glad I haven’t.  But I have a gut feeling that once this report gets circulated, it will only be a matter of time before it rears itself in my neck of the woods.  Truth is there is no reason it shouldn’t.  What you’ll see below is research garnered from hundreds of coaches supporting the idea that the benefits of utilizing the shield punt scheme far outweigh the risks.  As Keith Herring, the head coach at Brentwood High School (MO) told us, "We were leery when we put it in.  Until you see it happen you’re hesitant.  But it really does work."   You’ll also find that for the first time in this report, X&O Labs published actual comments from the survey that we released last week (I should point out that we only asked coaches who have experience either running the shield punt or returning punts against the shield punt to complete the survey).  The reason is simple: Our coaches loved to discuss this scheme, and they want to sell you on it, because they are sold on it themselves. 

Among the hundreds of coaches we surveyed, 72.8 percent use the shield punt exclusively in their package.  The only situation they won’t is when punting from their own end zone.  So feel free to contact them to learn more about it, they won’t hesitate to return your call.  In fact, our coaches were so outspoken about the advantages of running the shield punt, we listed them below for you:

Advantages of Using the Shield Punt Formation:

  • Better coverage down the field: The shield punt puts seven players in coverage at the snap of the ball, all seven players on the line of scrimmage.  Although the numbers may equate to traditional style punts, the presence of the middle shield players and a three yard spilt along the line of scrimmage allows all players up front to get off into their lanes immediately and cover the kick.
  • Quicker snap to kick time: 70.6 percent of coaches average between 2.0-2.4 seconds per kick using the shield punt.  Reason being almost all of them teaches a two-step release:  Step with the non-kicking foot then boot the ball out of there.  Distance isn’t a priority as much as speed and coverage when using this style.
  • Simpler blocking assignments: We found this to be the most simple of them all.  While most use man schemes, we detail examples of both in the report.
  • Better personnel on the field: The coaches that took this survey were intense about special teams, 39.1 percent were special teams coordinators at the high school and collegiate level.  So, they don’t think about resting their best players on punt.  Bill Stewart, the former coach at The University of West Virginia called it "the best play in football."  You’re about to see why.
  • Keep defenses "defensive" and not "pro-active:"  We got this philosophy from Travis Walch, the special teams coordinator from the University of St. Thomas (MN), who switched to the shield punt in ’09 because he was sick of defending it.  We’ve found coaches will mix a rugby (rollout) style with a conventional drop and kick style.  Which means many will put one of their better athletes at punter – and that makes the variable for a fake rise through the roof.  Instead of defenses getting revved up to block their kick, they were paranoid of the fake.  Some coaches shared their fakes with us, but that will be revealed in another report (when we can verify who they play!).
  • It’s nearly impossible to block: This may surprise you, but of all the coaches we spoke to personally when developing this report, only one of them had one blocked and it was because of a poor snap.  Sure, we did interview a few coaches who thought they had this scheme figured out (in Case Four) but because of all the issues a shield punt presents, the majority of defensive coaches would rather set up a return than a block.

Case 1: Rugby Style, Drop Back Style or Both?

 

When executing the shield punt, it seems you have three options with the punter.  After reaching out to coaches, here’s what we found:

  • 50.0 percent use a pure drop and kick punter with a two-step release
  • 47.5 percent will mix drop and kick with rugby rollout styles
  • 2.5 percent exclusively use a rollout and kick

It seems that you either have an athlete that can handle the rugby style or you don’t and in turn can’t run it effectively.  Whichever style you choose, it’s important to point out the depth of the punter.  According to our research 66 percent of coaches aligned him at 14 yards.  Herring, whose teams hadn’t had a punt blocked in three seasons, toyed around with the idea of using a rollout style.  "We played around with rugby, but in the four years I’ve ran it, most guys were better just traditionally punting it so we stayed with it," said Herring.  "I like two things about it:  we get down the field quickly because we’re so spread out; also a lot of people don’t know how to line up to it.  Guys line up so wide on the tackles that they take themselves out of the play."

 

Walch, at the risk of being too predictable decided to vary the launch points of his punter from rugby to drop back.  "Why not try to use two different launch points on punt?" he says.  "You do it on offense and defense so why not special teams?  By doing this, the defense doesn’t know if he’s punting out of pocket or directly behind long snapper.  You’ve already put doubt in the punt blockers minds."

Walch used to have his punter roll either way and decide on his own accord when to punt.  Now, he coaches up the steps.  "We had two or three that were blocked because he had indecision on whether or not he should punt it," said Walch.  "Now we have designed steps, side shuffle, turn his body (for three steps) and on number four he’ll punt it away.  We don’t have a four and a second launch point like we used to."

>> X&O Labs Members: Login here to continue reading

Join X&O Labs to Continue Reading...

Plus, get up to 4 FREE books!

When you join X&O Labs, you'll get instant access to the full-length version of this report — including access to everything in The LAB and Film Room. That’s over 4,000 reports and videos. Plus, if you join today, you'll also receive up to 4 FREE books mailed directly to your home or office (and every year you renew your membership)!